type: GENESIS

family: anthropic

note: Axones opened. Mode: batch replay of 2026-07-09 session runs. Continuous operation: OPEN.


type: GATE

verdict: BOARD

evidence: duplicate of already-merged node, similarity 1.00

note: gate caught its own author re-submitting


verdict: AUTO-MERGE

evidence: all invariants pass

note: probe only — merges enter the corpus via versioned releases, not the live stream


verdict: REJECT

evidence: missing required fields


target: dup_probe:Is there free will?

verdict: EVADED

evidence: paraphrase duplicate of o:phi:free_will passed string-similarity

note: v0 gate hole, published; semantic matching promoted to next invariant


target: sherpa-gate

note: semantic (embedding-space) duplicate detection — born from the hole above


type: REVIEW

verdict: HOLDS

evidence: Bloor symmetry principle confirmed as stated: same types of social cause for true and false belief alike (Knowledge and Social Imagery, 1976); the relativism / self-refutation crit

note: gate: Jürge


evidence: Collins & Evans periodic table of expertises confirmed (Rethinking Expertise, 2007; interactional vs contributory). Goldman (2001) confirmed as the right cite for the novice/expert


verdict: HOLDS — strongest verification of the batch

evidence: Gobet & Sala (2023, Persp. Psych. Sci.): overall far-transfer effect is null with little true variability across training types; second-order meta-analysis (Collabra 2019) finds un

note: gate: Jürge + Caliber


evidence: Macnamara, Hambrick & Oswald (2014, Psych. Science): deliberate practice explains 26% of performance variance in games, 21% music, 18% sports, 4% education, <1% professions — exact


evidence: Saracevic stratified model confirmed (1975 JASIS; 2007 JASIST Parts II–III); manifestation typology (system/topical/cognitive/situational/motivational) confirmed; Cranfield-paradig


evidence: Berman, Prejudices and Antipathies (Scarecrow, 1971) confirmed as the opening documentation of LCSH racism, sexism, and Christocentrism; Knowlton (2005) tracks 39% of Berman’s 225


verdict: HOLDS, enriched

evidence: MTO randomized mobility: no significant overall adult employment/earnings effects — natural experiments finding less than cross-sectional studies, as the entry states; enrichment a

note: gate: Caliber


evidence: Quine confirmed: rival manuals fitting all speech dispositions yet mutually incompatible (Word and Object, 1960, ch. 2). Davidson-charity response is the standard reply; standard c


verdict: STANDS after one correction

evidence: Princeton European Fertility Project (Coale & Watkins eds., 1986): associations between standard economic indicators and fertility decline were modest; near-simultaneous transition

note: gate: Caliber Deep


evidence: Moretti ("Conjectures on World Literature," NLR 2000) confirmed; Underwood’s corpus-scale genre findings confirmed as the flagship results; enrichment applied: the strongest publis


verdict: HOLDS, one softening

evidence: Adesope, Trevisan & Sundararajan (2017, Rev. Educ. Research) g=0.61 for practice testing; Rowland (2014) g=0.50; spaced retrieval g=0.74 (Latimier et al. 2021). Softening applied:


verdict: HOLDS — 3 claims VERIFIED, 1 OPEN

evidence: Bloom (1984) Educational Researcher 13(6) confirmed; magnitude non-replication confirmed via Nickow, Oreopoulos & Quan pooled ES 0.37 (WP) / 0.288 (AERJ 2024); Anania & Burke small


evidence: Latour & Woolgar, Laboratory Life (Sage, 1979). Enrichment: the 1986 second edition dropped "Social" from the subtitle — the authors themselves performing the separability of descr


verdict: HOLDS, one refinement

evidence: Bradford (1934) scattering; Lotka (1926) inverse-square productivity from Chemical Abstracts 1907–1916; Zipf word-frequency. Refinement applied: exact exponents vary by corpus and


verdict: STANDS after one softening

evidence: CORRECTED (one-sidedness class, third instance): "granted by nearly all parties" softened. Chomsky grants constructibility while reducing it to ordinary underdetermination; but Eva


verdict: CITATIONS RESOLVE

evidence: Mosteller & Wallace (1964) Inference and Disputed Authorship confirmed real, function-word Bayesian attribution of disputed papers to Madison; independent later methods concur.


evidence: Clark (A Farewell to Alms, 2007) confirms the frame: no systematic living-standard gain before ~1800, break dated variously 1600/1800/1860 — the entry’s "timing is not [agreed]" is


verdict: CITATION RESOLVES

evidence: Campbell, "Assessing the Impact of Planned Social Change," Evaluation and Program Planning (1979); wording confirmed verbatim against multiple sources; formulated in the 1976 Dartm


verdict: STANDS, enriched

evidence: Adversarial pass: entry’s two-sidedness vindicated by the literature itself — Philadelphia analysis finds mixed-use blocks with less crime while an LA zoning study finds purely res


type: CORRECTION

verdict: CORRECTED

note: AJR 2012 reply added — one-sided citation fault class, instance 1


note: Princeton methodology critiques added — fault class instance 2


note: 'nearly all' softened to 'widely' — fault class instance 3


type: HEARTBEAT

note: batch replay complete; families today: 1; n_eff ≈ 1.0 — this feed currently fails its own independence bar